Mightycause vs Givebutter: Which is Right for You?
Quick Takeaways
- Both Mightycause and Givebutter offer $0 subscription fee options, but Givebutter charges $29-$348 per year for additional features
- Mightycause and Givebutter serve nonprofits with different needs and priorities
- Mightycause is ideal for established nonprofits seeking comprehensive CRM tools and proven reliability, while Givebutter works better for newer organizations prioritizing simplicity
- Key differences include experience, donor management capabilities, and long-term platform stability
Introduction
Mightycause vs Givebutter is one of the most common comparisons nonprofits make when choosing a fundraising platform. While both advertise $0 subscription fees, they differ significantly in experience, pricing structure, CRM depth, and long-term reliability. This guide breaks down exactly which platform is the better fit based on your organization’s size, goals, and growth stage.
When choosing between fundraising platforms, it’s not just about pricing. While both Mightycause and Givebutter advertise free platforms, the depth of features, platform maturity, and donor management capabilities vary significantly. This comparison will help you understand which platform aligns best with your nonprofit’s goals.
Mightycause vs Givebutter: Feature & Pricing Comparison
| Feature | Mightycause | Givebutter |
| Founded | 2006 (19 years of experience) | 2016 (9 years of experience) |
| Monthly Subscription | $0 | $0 (or $29-$348/year for Givebutter Plus) |
| Platform Fee | Average fee of 0.95% and $0.30 | 3% if tipping is disabled,
0% with donor tips enabled |
| Price Guarantee | Yes – never pay more than 1.99% + $0.30 | No price guarantee |
| Donor CRM | Full-service CRM included | Basic CRM (advanced requires Plus subscription) |
| Ideal For | Established nonprofits needing comprehensive tools | Newer organizations wanting simple setup |
About Mightycause
Mightycause helps nonprofits of all sizes raise funds effectively through a mature, feature-rich platform that’s been refined over nearly two decades of nonprofit experience.
Overview: Founded in 2006 as Razoo, Mightycause has spent nearly 20 years perfecting online fundraising for nonprofits. The platform serves over 150,000 active users and has processed hundreds of millions in donations. With $0 monthly subscription fees and a Price Guarantee that caps fees at 1.99% + $0.30 per transaction, Mightycause provides predictable, affordable fundraising without sacrificing features.
Strengths
- 19 years of proven experience: Mightycause has been serving nonprofits since 2006, giving the platform nearly two decades to refine features, fix bugs, and understand nonprofit needs
- Price Guarantee protection: Unlike competitors, Mightycause guarantees you’ll never pay more than 1.99% + $0.30 per transaction, providing budget certainty even when donors don’t cover fees
- Full-service CRM included: Comprehensive donor management, advanced analytics, and data integration come standard at $0/month — features that cost extra elsewhere
- Platform stability: With nearly 20 years in business, Mightycause offers institutional knowledge and proven reliability that newer platforms can’t match
Considerations
Mightycause works best for nonprofits that value comprehensive features and long-term stability. Organizations seeking the absolute simplest setup (with fewer features) might find newer platforms initially easier, though they may outgrow them quickly.
About Givebutter
Givebutter is a newer fundraising platform founded in 2016, known for its user-friendly interface and focus on simplicity.
Overview: Givebutter launched in 2016 and has quickly gained popularity with its clean design and straightforward approach to fundraising. The platform offers free fundraising with optional donor tips, though advanced CRM features require a paid Givebutter Plus subscription starting at $29/month.
Strengths
- Clean, modern interface that’s easy to navigate for first-time users
- Strong customer support and regular platform updates based on user feedback
Limitations
- Less than half the experience: Founded in 2016, Givebutter has only 9 years of experience compared to Mightycause’s 19 years, meaning less time to encounter and solve edge cases
- No price guarantee: Without a price cap, unpredictable fees can impact your budget if donor fee coverage varies
- Limited CRM without paying extra: Advanced donor management features require a Givebutter Plus subscription ($348-$405/year), adding costs that Mightycause includes free
- Platform fee when tips disabled: Disabling donor tips triggers a 3% platform fee across all campaigns, while Mightycause maintains its 1.99% + $0.30 cap regardless
Mightycause vs Givebutter: Which Fundraising Platform Is Right for You?
Choose Mightycause if you want nearly two decades of proven reliability, comprehensive CRM tools included free, and price guarantee protection. Choose Givebutter if you’re a very new organization prioritizing immediate simplicity over long-term features.
Decision Guide:
- If you need proven platform stability and institutional knowledge from 19 years of serving nonprofits, Mightycause is the better fit
- If you want predictable costs with a Price Guarantee that caps fees regardless of donor behavior, choose Mightycause
- If you need full-service CRM features without paying extra subscriptions, Mightycause delivers more value
- If you’re a brand new nonprofit with minimal donor data and want the fastest possible setup, Givebutter may work initially (though you’ll likely need to upgrade as you grow)
Why People Choose Mightycause Over Givebutter
Most nonprofits switch to Mightycause because it offers greater platform maturity, more comprehensive donor management tools, and price protection that Givebutter doesn’t provide.
FAQs: Mightycause vs Givebutter
Q: Is Mightycause better than Givebutter?
A: It depends on your organization’s maturity and needs. For established nonprofits requiring comprehensive CRM tools, price guarantees, and proven platform stability, Mightycause is typically the better fit thanks to its 19 years of nonprofit experience and included full-service features.
Q: Why do people switch from Givebutter to Mightycause?
A: Nonprofits often switch due to needing more advanced donor management (which requires paying extra for Givebutter Plus), wanting price guarantee protection, and seeking the reliability of a platform with nearly two decades of nonprofit experience.
Q: How do the pricing models compare?
A: Both offer $0 monthly fees, but Mightycause provides a Price Guarantee capping fees at 1.99% + $0.30 per transaction, while Givebutter charges 3% when tips are disabled and offers no price cap. Givebutter’s advanced CRM requires Givebutter Plus at $348-$405/year, while Mightycause includes full CRM features at no extra cost.
Q: Which platform has more experience?
A: Mightycause was founded in 2006 and has 19 years of experience serving nonprofits. Givebutter was founded in 2016 and has 9 years of experience — less than half the institutional knowledge.
Q: Do both platforms charge processing fees?
A: Yes, both charge payment processing fees. The difference is that Mightycause guarantees your total fees won’t exceed 1.99% + $0.29 per transaction regardless of donor tip coverage while Givebutter charges 3% if donor tipping is disabled.
Final Verdict
Both platforms deliver value, but for most established nonprofits, Mightycause is the smarter long-term choice thanks to its 19 years of proven experience, comprehensive CRM included free, and Price Guarantee protection.
Platform maturity matters. With nearly two decades of serving nonprofits, Mightycause has encountered and solved challenges that newer platforms haven’t yet faced. Combined with included full-service CRM tools (that cost extra elsewhere) and price guarantee protection, Mightycause offers the reliability and features that growing nonprofits need.
Ready to Decide?
Start fundraising free with Mightycause
Sources & References
- Mightycause Pricing
- Mightycause Nonprofit Pricing – Support Center
- Givebutter Fees & Pricing
- Givebutter Guarantee Pricing Model
- Mightycause Reviews on G2
- Givebutter Reviews on G2