Giving Day Platforms vs P2P Fundraising Tools: Key Differences Explained

TL;DR: Giving Day Platforms vs P2P Fundraising Tools

Giving Days are high-energy, 24-hour community sprints best for urgency and new donor acquisition. Peer-to-Peer (P2P) fundraising is a marathon fueled by personal networks, ideal for long-term engagement. Most successful nonprofits combine both to maximize reach and revenue.

If you’ve ever tried to raise money for a good cause, you’ve probably heard terms like “Giving Day” and “peer-to-peer fundraising.” They both sound exciting, and they both help nonprofits bring in donations. But they work in very different ways.

So, which one is right for your organization? Let’s break it all down in plain, simple terms.

What Is a Giving Day?

A Giving Day is a special fundraising event that lasts for a short time — usually just 24 hours. During that window, lots of nonprofits raise money at the same time on one shared website or platform.

Think of it like a community-wide fundraising party. Everyone shows up on the same day, competes on leaderboards, and works hard to win prizes and matching grants. Donors love it because they feel like part of something big. Nonprofits love it because the energy and urgency push people to give right away.

Some well-known Giving Days include:

• GivingTuesday — A global day of giving held the Tuesday after Thanksgiving.
• Colorado Gives Day — A statewide event for Colorado nonprofits.
• North Texas Giving Day — One of the largest community giving events in the country.

⚠️ Keep in Mind (The Challenge)

Giving Days are “noisy.” Because thousands of organizations are posting at once, it takes a high-intensity marketing effort to stand out. It’s a sprint that requires significant preparation for a very short window of time.

What Is Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Fundraising?

Peer-to-peer fundraising (also called P2P) is when your supporters raise money for you by reaching out to their friends and family.

Here’s how it works: A nonprofit creates a main campaign page. Then supporters — called fundraisers — set up their own personal pages linked to that campaign. Each fundraiser shares their page with people they know and asks them to donate. Instead of the nonprofit doing all the asking, the supporters do it.

Common P2P fundraising campaigns include:

• Walk-a-thons and 5K runs — Participants collect pledges.
• Birthday fundraisers — Supporters ask for donations instead of gifts.
• Virtual challenges — Participants complete a task and ask for sponsors.

⚠️ Keep in Mind (The Challenge)

P2P requires “fundraiser coaching.” You aren’t just managing a campaign; you’re managing people. You need to provide them with the right tools, images, and encouragement to ensure they actually follow through on their goals.

The Comparison: At a Glance

Which One Should You Choose?

Use a Giving Day Platform if…

• You want to raise a lot of money in a very short amount of time.
• You want to reach new donors through community-wide “buzz.”
• You’re part of a community foundation or regional network.
• You want to compete for prize money and matching grants.

Use a P2P Fundraising Tool if…

• You want to engage your existing supporters in a deeper way.
• You’re planning an event like a run, walk, or challenge.
• You want to grow your donor network organically through “friend-of-a-friend” asks.
• You want donors to feel a personal connection to the fundraiser.

How Mightycause Bridges the Gap

Choosing between these two strategies doesn’t have to be a headache. Mightycause is one of the few platforms designed to handle the high-octane intensity of a Giving Day while providing the intimate, customizable tools needed for year-round P2P fundraising.

Why Nonprofits Choose Mightycause:

• Reliable, Scalable Tech: Built to handle thousands of donations per minute without crashing.
• Real-time Gamification: Live leaderboards and prize tracking to keep the Giving Day energy high.
• Easy Fundraiser Tools: Supporters can set up a personal page in minutes, with no technical skills required.
• Donor CRM Included: Don’t just collect checks; build relationships with a built-in management system.
• Donor-Covered Fees: Donors can choose to cover transaction costs, meaning your nonprofit keeps more of every dollar.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the two? A Giving Day is a community-wide event with a hard deadline. P2P fundraising is a strategy where individuals raise money for you using their own networks.

Can small nonprofits participate in Giving Days? Absolutely! Giving Days often level the playing field because the host organization provides the marketing muscle and training that small shops might not have on their own.

Is P2P only for athletic events? No! It works for birthdays, “Giving Tuesday” personal pages, and even “tribute” campaigns in memory of loved ones.

Can I use both at the same time? Yes—and you should! Many successful nonprofits allow their board members or “super-fans” to create P2P pages during a Giving Day. This combines the urgency of the 24-hour clock with the personal reach of P2P.

Ready to grow your impact?

Whether you’re looking to join a community Giving Day or launch your next big Peer-to-Peer challenge, our team is here to help.

Request a Demo | Download our 2026 Giving Day Playbook